What Should a CRNA Do With Their Old 401(k) or 403(b)?

If you’re a CRNA, a big part of your retirement nest egg is likely tied up in your 401(k) or 403(b). But here’s what many healthcare professionals don’t realize: there are three critical decision points that will either maximize your retirement wealth or quietly drain it away over the next 20 to 30 years.  These decisions seem simple on the surface, but they’re loaded with hidden traps. Getting even one wrong could easily cost you six figures in unnecessary fees, taxes, or lost opportunities. So what are these three decision points, and how do you navigate them without making costly mistakes?

Decision Point #1: Understanding the True Cost of Your Retirement Plan

The first decision point is understanding the true cost of your current retirement plan. Thousands of CRNAs are sitting on substantial retirement balances right now but have no idea how much those accounts are costing them each year.  Consider this example: A CRNA with $600,000 in her 403(b) thought she was doing great because her account was growing. But when we dug into the fees, we discovered she was paying over $15,000 per year in hidden costs. That’s $15,000 that should have been growing for her retirement, gone every single year.  While things have improved in recent years, smaller retirement plans can still run two or even two and a half percent per year. To put that into perspective, if you have $500,000 in your account, that’s $10,000 to $12,500 in annual fees regardless of how the market performs.

Decision Point #2: Control and Flexibility

Even if your 401(k) or 403(b) has very low costs, that doesn’t automatically make it the best option. There’s something most CRNAs don’t consider: ease of access and control over your own money.  Some retirement plans make every little transaction feel like pulling teeth. You want to rebalance? You have to submit paperwork. You want to take a withdrawal or do a Roth conversion? Good luck navigating an outdated online system.  Here’s the thing: one of the main goals of personal finance is to make your money simple so you can think about it less. Human nature tells us that the harder something is to do, the less likely we are to do it. If your plan makes even basic steps a hassle, you may end up putting them off. Missing a rebalance or delaying a Roth conversion could ultimately cost you money.

Decision Point #3: The Consolidation Challenge

The third decision point that most CRNAs completely overlook is consolidation. Plenty of healthcare professionals have worked for eight, nine, even ten different employers. Each time they left, they left their old 401(k) or 403(b) behind. Before long, they’ve become collectors of retirement accounts.  At first, this might not sound like a problem. But when retirement comes and it’s time to start taking income, things get very messy. Which account do you draw from first? How do you avoid overlapping investments? How do you even know your true balance when everything is spread across half a dozen plans?  The more consolidated your accounts are, the simpler your life becomes and the easier it is to feel confident that you’re managing your money effectively. The cost trap, the control dilemma, and the consolidation challenge all create the same fundamental problem: they prevent you from having clarity and confidence about your retirement money.

The Strategic Rollover Framework

There’s a systematic approach that addresses all three of these issues at once. It’s not just about moving your money; it’s about creating what I call the strategic rollover framework.  This framework starts with a simple principle: your retirement accounts should work for you, not against you.

Step 1: The True Cost Audit

You need to get a handle on your plan’s total cost. Look at everything: the internal costs of your investments, the record keeping fees, administrative charges, and any advisory fees. Add it all up to see your true all in cost.  Then compare that to what you’d pay if you rolled your money into a traditional IRA where you can choose from thousands of low cost investment options and you’re in the driver’s seat.

Step 2: The Control Assessment

Ask yourself which option is going to give you more control and ease of use. The easier it is to manage, the more likely you are to take advantage of the strategies that will help you get the most from your retirement savings.  With an IRA, you usually have complete control. You can trade, rebalance, convert to Roth, or take withdrawals quickly and easily without the extra red tape.

Step 3: The Consolidation Strategy

This is where you bring everything together under one roof. With everything in fewer places, it’s so much easier to see your big picture, track your investments, and plan where your retirement income will come from.

Two Critical Considerations Before You Make Any Moves

Before you make any moves, there are two critical considerations you need to understand.

The After-Tax Contribution Split

Not all of your balance is treated the same way in a rollover. If your plan allowed after tax contributions, that money can roll into a Roth IRA where it will continue to grow tax free. But the growth on those after tax dollars has to roll into a traditional IRA where it is still tax deferred.

The Age 55 Rule

If you retire from your employer in the year you turn age 55 or later, you can take penalty free withdrawals from that company’s 401(k) or 403(b). You don’t have to wait until age 59 and a half.  So if you’re planning to retire in your mid to late fifties, it may make sense to keep at least part of your balance in your 401(k) or 403(b) for penalty free access while the rest can be rolled into an IRA for greater control and flexibility.

Making the Right Choice for Your Situation

When you’re deciding what to do with your 401(k) or 403(b) after you retire, remember the strategic rollover framework addresses the three critical decision points: the cost trap, the control dilemma, and the consolidation challenge.  But here’s the thing: every CRNA’s situation is unique. What works perfectly well for one person may not be the right choice for another. These decisions can have a huge impact on your taxes, your flexibility, and your peace of mind in retirement.  Don’t rush the process. Take the time to evaluate your options carefully and make the choice that aligns with your goals and your lifestyle. Your retirement should be as carefully planned as your most complex case in the OR.  

Ready to see how Oak Capital Advisors can help? Schedule a meeting.

Click here to download the Retirement Readiness Checklist